PLAY GAME
Member
The Insignia 40" FE Series is $119.99 right now, which is twenty bucks under the 40" Roku and ten under the 32" Roku. A 40-inch Fire TV for less than a 32-inch Roku should be the easiest recommendation on this forum. Then I looked at the rating line: 4.5 stars from 0 ratings. Not a low score, no score. The listing shows a star average with nothing behind it, and the only other number attached to the product is "3K+ bought in past month." That combination is the whole reason I started this thread, because I cannot work out whether that's a new listing that hasn't collected reviews yet or a listing that got reset.
The two Rokus are the known quantity. Both show 4.5 stars, and the counts are 61,017 for the 32-inch and 61,399 for the 40-inch, which tells you these are the same product line reviewed together rather than two separately vetted sets. Both claim 10K+ bought in the past month. The 40-inch at $149.99 is a $30 step over the 32-inch at $129.99, and for that you get eight more inches of the same 1080p panel class. If this is going in a bedroom or a kitchen, the 32-inch is fine and saves the money. If it's the main TV in a small living room, thirty dollars for eight inches is the cheapest upgrade in this comparison.
What bothers me about all three listings is how little is actually stated. Every one of them says 1080p and essentially stops there. No brightness figure, no contrast, no refresh rate, no panel type, no dimensions, no HDMI count on any of the three. The Roku bullets repeat themselves word for word, and "Roku Smart Picture cleans up incoming TV signals" is doing a lot of vague work. Nobody should read "bright 1080p Full HD" as a measured claim. It's a phrase, and it's on both Rokus identically.
The Insignia's other problem is the ecosystem. It's a Fire TV with the Alexa remote, so you're buying into Amazon's interface and its ad-heavy home screen, and the only feature bullet on the entire listing is the resolution. One bullet. For a TV that's supposedly outselling the Rokus at 3K+ a month, that's a thin listing, and thin listings are where I get suspicious. The Rokus at least have a track record you can read through, even if the reviews are pooled across sizes and you can't tell which size the complaints are about.
My read: the 40" Roku at $149.99 is the safe buy and the one I'd put in a room where people will actually watch things. The 32" Roku at $129.99 only makes sense if the wall is small. The Insignia is the interesting gamble at $119.99, and I'd only take it if I could return it locally without a fight. What I want to know from anyone who has one: does the Insignia NS40-FEFL26 actually have a live review page that Amazon is hiding, or is that 4.5 from 0 ratings as empty as it looks?
What the listings say (as of Nov 17)
The two Rokus are the known quantity. Both show 4.5 stars, and the counts are 61,017 for the 32-inch and 61,399 for the 40-inch, which tells you these are the same product line reviewed together rather than two separately vetted sets. Both claim 10K+ bought in the past month. The 40-inch at $149.99 is a $30 step over the 32-inch at $129.99, and for that you get eight more inches of the same 1080p panel class. If this is going in a bedroom or a kitchen, the 32-inch is fine and saves the money. If it's the main TV in a small living room, thirty dollars for eight inches is the cheapest upgrade in this comparison.
What bothers me about all three listings is how little is actually stated. Every one of them says 1080p and essentially stops there. No brightness figure, no contrast, no refresh rate, no panel type, no dimensions, no HDMI count on any of the three. The Roku bullets repeat themselves word for word, and "Roku Smart Picture cleans up incoming TV signals" is doing a lot of vague work. Nobody should read "bright 1080p Full HD" as a measured claim. It's a phrase, and it's on both Rokus identically.
The Insignia's other problem is the ecosystem. It's a Fire TV with the Alexa remote, so you're buying into Amazon's interface and its ad-heavy home screen, and the only feature bullet on the entire listing is the resolution. One bullet. For a TV that's supposedly outselling the Rokus at 3K+ a month, that's a thin listing, and thin listings are where I get suspicious. The Rokus at least have a track record you can read through, even if the reviews are pooled across sizes and you can't tell which size the complaints are about.
My read: the 40" Roku at $149.99 is the safe buy and the one I'd put in a room where people will actually watch things. The 32" Roku at $129.99 only makes sense if the wall is small. The Insignia is the interesting gamble at $119.99, and I'd only take it if I could return it locally without a fight. What I want to know from anyone who has one: does the Insignia NS40-FEFL26 actually have a live review page that Amazon is hiding, or is that 4.5 from 0 ratings as empty as it looks?
What the listings say (as of Nov 17)
| Spec | INSIGNIA Store | Roku Store | Roku Store |
|---|---|---|---|
| Price | $119.99 | $129.99 | $149.99 |
| Amazon rating | 4.5 (0 ratings) | 4.5 (61017 ratings) | 4.5 (61399 ratings) |
| Bestseller rank | #15 | #2 | #4 |