The Odyssey 4K disc tops out at 111 nits and the shadows look grey - SDR in an HDR wrapper

LLLisa

Member
A whole-film brightness graph that never gets past 111 nits is the number going around on The Odyssey UHD, and the heatmaps people are posting show almost nothing outside the Rec.709 triangle. That is SDR reference brightness and SDR colour, delivered in a container that flips your TV into HDR mode. The German release is November 18, so a lot of discs are about to land in players with expectations set by a film shot entirely on IMAX film cameras.

The low peak on its own does not bother me much. Nolan's discs have leaned restrained before and I would rather have a dim, stable grade than fake specular highlights bolted on in post. What bothers me is the second complaint. The HD Movie Source reviewer says blacks looked lifted and grey on a calibrated LG C9, with artefacts in the shadows of the Cyclops cave that he also saw on the regular Blu-ray. His fix was dropping brightness to -3 on a Panasonic UB9000, after which both the grey floor and the shadow junk went away.

That fix is the interesting part. If knocking the player down three clicks cleans it up, the problem sits near black level in the encode or the grade, not in some missing HDR expansion. Nobody has measured the German pressing yet, and that comparison matters because a different authoring house could behave differently.

Hold off on the steelbook until someone with a meter and a second player confirms whether this is the master or the encode, because one of those gets a reissue and the other never does.
 

XLZ451

Member
Every Nolan UHD since Interstellar has had people complaining about HDR. Dim grade is the intent. The raised blacks claim is the only thing I'd take seriously here.
 
Top